What writing an option means

Option writing (also called selling an option) means taking the other side of the buyer’s contract. The writer receives the premium on day one and, in exchange, accepts an obligation: if the buyer uses the option, the writer must pay the payoff. Where the call and put post looked at what a buyer pays and risks, this post is the mirror image, and it is why the position needs margin: money the writer must keep deposited with the broker because the possible loss is far larger than the premium received.

This is a description of the arithmetic, not a suggestion to take either side. It is part of the options module in Risk, Leverage and Your Own Brain, on the same hypothetical Sample Index at 20000, with a lot of 75 units and a contract value of ₹15,00,000.

The formula

At expiry, with S the index level and K the strike. This is the buyer’s formula from the earlier post with the sign reversed:

Short call, profit or loss  =  ( premium  −  max(S − K, 0) )  ×  lot size
Short put,  profit or loss  =  ( premium  −  max(K − S, 0) )  ×  lot size

Most a writer can gain      =  premium × lot size
Short call: loss has no upper limit as S rises
Short put:  worst case is S = 0:   ( premium − K ) × lot size

Worked example: one lot, strike 20000, premium 343 points

The writer receives 343 points × 75 = ₹25,725 and that is the most the writer can ever keep. Breakevens are the buyer’s breakevens: 20343 for the call, 19657 for the put.

Index at expiry Move from 20000 Short call: profit or loss (₹) …as % of assumed margin Short put: profit or loss (₹) …as % of assumed margin
18,500 −7.5% 25,725 14.3% −86,775 −48.2%
19,000 −5% 25,725 14.3% −49,275 −27.4%
19,500 −2.5% 25,725 14.3% −11,775 −6.5%
19,800 −1% 25,725 14.3% 10,725 6%
20,000 0% 25,725 14.3% 25,725 14.3%
20,350 1.75% −525 −0.3% 25,725 14.3%
20,500 2.5% −11,775 −6.5% 25,725 14.3%
21,000 5% −49,275 −27.4% 25,725 14.3%
21,500 7.5% −86,775 −48.2% 25,725 14.3%
22,000 10% −1,24,275 −69% 25,725 14.3%
23,000 15% −1,99,275 −110.7% 25,725 14.3%

Look at each column. For the short call the gain stops at ₹25,725; on the other side the loss grows with every point the index rises: at 22000 it is already ₹1,24,275, about 4.8 times the best-case gain. The short put’s loss is bounded by the index reaching zero, at ₹14,74,275, a bound that is of little comfort in practice. In both cases the premium is the whole upside and a small part of the downside.

Margin: why the deposit exists

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) circular SEBI/HO/MRD/TPD-1/P/CIR/2024/132 of 1 October 2024, as restated in its SEBI Master Circular for Stock Exchanges and Clearing Corporations, Chapter 5 (Exchange Traded Derivatives) (30 December 2024, read on 1 November 2026), says applicable upfront margins must be collected from the client in advance of the trade (master circular paragraph 1.2.14). For short options on the day of expiry it adds an additional extreme loss margin (ELM) of 2% on short options due to expire that day, whether open at the start of the day or initiated during it (paragraph 2.2.4, effective 20 November 2024). It also removed the offset benefit of calendar spreads on expiry day (paragraph 1.2.7, effective 1 February 2025). Rules change, so check the current rule.

Actual margin amounts are set by the exchange and the clearing corporation, and change with the market and the position. For the table above, this post assumes a round 12% of contract value: ₹1,80,000 per lot. That number is for illustration only. On it, the premium received is 14.3% of margin, while an index move of 10% against a short call is a loss of about 69% of it, and a larger move takes the loss past the whole deposit. What happens to a shortfall is set by the broker’s and the exchange’s rules, so check them before relying on a figure like this one. If the 2% expiry-day add-on were applied to the contract value (the paragraph quoted above does not say which value it applies to, so this is an assumption), it would be ₹30,000 more.

The number of option positions still outstanding at any time is called open interest; for every written option there is a bought one, so open interest counts contracts, not people on one side.

What SEBI’s studies show about this side

SEBI’s August 2026 behaviour study found that, in FY 2025-26 (the financial year to March 2026), about 2% of the individual traders it classified by how they traded options were mainly option sellers, against about 97% who were mainly buyers (the study’s page 17; check it for the exact group counted); its profitability study found that options accounted for about 92% of the futures and options (F&O) segment’s aggregate losses that year. These are SEBI’s figures from the studies discussed in the F&O numbers post, quoted here and not recomputed; they are research statistics, and they do not say that either side does better. How income and losses from this activity are taxed is a separate matter in the Tax series.

Common mistakes

  • Reading the premium as the return. It is the maximum gain, collected in advance. Against margin it can look modest, and the loss that sits on the other side of the table can be many times larger.
  • Calling a put’s loss “limited” because it has a floor. The floor is the index at zero. The practical question is how much margin and capital stand behind a position, and a bounded loss can still be larger than the account.
  • Treating margin as the most you can lose. Margin is a deposit set by the exchange’s risk model. The last row of the table shows a loss larger than the assumed margin.
  • Ignoring expiry-day rules. The 2% add-on and the end of the calendar-spread offset (both above) apply on the day of expiry, when moves can be quickest. The expiry post covers the day itself.

Takeaway: An option writer’s gain is capped at the premium received, while the loss on a short call has no cap and on a short put stops only when the index reaches zero. Margin is a deposit against that asymmetry, not a ceiling on the loss, as the table’s last row shows.