Tax Year 2026-27 (FY 2026-27) is the label for the rules below. The worked example redeems on 31 March 2026, which falls in FY (financial year) 2025-26, when the earlier Income-tax Act, 1961 applied. It uses the rates and exemption described for Tax Year 2026-27 to illustrate the mechanics, and it has not been checked against the 1961 Act’s rules for that year. It is not a Tax Year 2026-27 return.

A SIP is not one investment

A SIP — systematic investment plan, a fixed sum invested every month — feels like one. One instruction, one fund, one folio, one line on your statement. For tax, it is nothing of the sort.

Every instalment is a separate acquisition, with its own date, its own cost, and its own holding-period clock. A five-year monthly SIP isn’t one investment held five years — it’s sixty investments, the oldest held five years and the newest held a month.

That single fact drives everything else in this post.

FIFO: which units leave first

When you redeem part of a holding, which units did you sell? You didn’t specify, and it matters enormously, because different lots have different costs and different holding periods.

The answer in practice is FIFO — first in, first out. The units you bought earliest are treated as the units sold first. For shares and units held in demat (electronic) form, FIFO is written into the Income-tax Act, 2025 itself (the provision on determining the cost and holding period of securities held through a depository). For mutual fund units held in a folio statement rather than demat, FIFO is the usual method, and it is the one capital gains statements generally use. The Act’s wording covers depository holdings, so that’s practice rather than a stated rule for a folio, and unusual holdings are worth checking.

Redeem  ->  oldest units go first
        ->  their cost and their purchase date determine the gain

FIFO tends to put the oldest units first, and the oldest units are the ones most likely to have crossed the twelve-month line and qualify for the long-term rate. Whether that helps depends on the market path: if the oldest units sit on a loss, the first units out carry that loss. FIFO also means your remaining holding is progressively made up of newer, shorter-held units — so a second redemption soon after is more likely to be short-term.

🧒 Explain it like I'm 10 (optional — skip if this is already clear)

Imagine a tall glass jar where you drop in a coin every month, and it can only be emptied from the bottom.

The coins at the bottom are the oldest ones. When you take money out, those come out first — that’s FIFO.

Now suppose coins become “special” once they’ve been in the jar a year, and special coins are cheaper to spend. The bottom coins are usually special. But if you empty a lot at once, you start reaching the newer coins near the top, and those aren’t special yet.

That’s the whole rule. Oldest out first, and how long each coin sat there decides what it costs you to spend it.

Worked example: sixty instalments, one redemption

A ₹10,000 monthly SIP into the fund used throughout this blog — UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund (regular plan, growth), NAVs (net asset values, the per-unit prices) from AMFI (the Association of Mutual Funds in India), as of 31 March 2026, used for illustration only — running from 1 April 2021 to 1 March 2026, redeemed in full on 31 March 2026. Each instalment buys at the latest NAV on or before the 1st of each month, as in the SIP post. A real SIP that falls on a holiday is allotted at the next business day’s NAV, which would make the gain ₹88,165. The figures below use the first rule:

Item  
Instalments 60
Total invested ₹6,00,000
Value at redemption ₹6,88,376
Total gain ₹88,376

Now the part a single “total gain” number hides. Of those 60 instalments, 48 had been held more than twelve months and 12 had not:

Item Lots Result
Long-term (held > 12 months) 48 ₹1,00,905
Short-term (held ≤ 12 months) 12 a loss of ₹12,529

One redemption, on one day, from one fund — producing a long-term gain and a short-term loss simultaneously. That can happen whenever the recent instalments are priced above the redemption NAV; the table above shows it in this example.

And the tax comes to nothing (Tax Year 2026-27)

Work it through:

  • The short-term result is a loss of ₹12,529, so there’s no short-term tax.
  • Under the set-off rules (as described there), a short-term loss is set off against the same year’s gains, and only what’s left over carries forward. Only a long-term gain is available here, so it comes off the long-term gain: ₹1,00,905 − ₹12,529 = ₹88,376.
  • That ₹88,376 is below the ₹1,25,000 annual exemption, so no tax is due on it.

Total tax on a ₹88,376 gain: zero. But notice what happened to the loss: it’s used up, and nothing carries forward. The long-term gain was already under the exemption, so absorbing the loss saved no tax at all. A short-term loss in a year with no gains to absorb it would instead carry forward, so the same lots can be taxed differently depending on what else lands in the same year.

The zero is real, and it’s worth being careful about what it does and doesn’t show. It isn’t clever planning — nobody arranged it. It’s the arithmetic of a moderate gain meeting a generous annual exemption. A larger SIP, or a stronger final year, and there would have been tax to pay. The lesson isn’t “SIPs are tax-free”; it’s that you cannot know your tax from the headline gain without splitting it by lot.

What follows practically

The exemption is per tax year. The ₹1,25,000 annual exemption applies to the long-term gains of one tax year; it does not carry over to the next.

Stopping a SIP doesn’t start any clock. Holding periods run from each instalment’s own purchase date, regardless of whether you’re still investing.

Switching between funds is generally a redemption. A switch — even within the same fund house — is generally treated as a sale of one scheme and a purchase of another, and so as a taxable event: the Act’s definition of a transfer covers a sale or exchange, though it doesn’t name a switch. The same generally applies to moving from regular to direct plans of the same fund (see the expense ratio post): the switch itself may be a taxable event, separate from the ongoing cost difference.

Dividend reinvestment creates new lots. Each reinvested payout is a fresh purchase with a fresh date and its own clock.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a SIP as one investment with one holding period. Each instalment stands alone.
  • Assuming a long-running SIP is all long-term. The most recent twelve months of instalments never are.
  • Expecting to choose which units you sell. FIFO decides for demat holdings, and it’s what capital gains statements generally use for folios.
  • Estimating tax from the total gain. The split between long and short lots is what determines it, and the two can point in opposite directions.
  • Forgetting that a switch is generally a sale. That includes a regular-to-direct switch of the same fund.

Sources

Takeaway: A SIP is as many separate investments as it has instalments, each with its own purchase date, and redemptions consume the oldest units first under FIFO. That’s why one redemption can produce a long-term gain and a short-term loss at once — and why the total gain tells you almost nothing about the tax until you’ve split it by lot.